The funeral and the partnership that built it

The first call after the death is usually to the funeral home, sometimes through hospice. The funeral director, or a representative, arrives within hours, sometimes in the middle of the night, and the surviving spouse meets, often for the first time, the person who will manage the body of their partner. Lynch has written extensively about this first encounter — the undertaker as the professional who handles what the family cannot — and about the strange intimacy of it. The funeral director takes the body with a kind of practiced courtesy that the surviving spouse usually remembers later as either deeply comforting or slightly chilling, depending on the director and the moment.

Some couples have pre-planned. They have chosen the cemetery plot, paid for the casket, written out the order of service. Most have not. Pre-planning, when it exists, is one of the great gifts of a long marriage to the surviving partner, because it removes a hundred decisions from the seventy-two-hour window of acute shock. When it does not exist, the surviving spouse must reconstruct preferences from memory, from offhand comments over the years, sometimes from a single conversation thirty years ago that may or may not still represent what the partner wanted. The absence of pre-planning is one of the most common regrets reported by widowed people in the year after the death.

A good funeral director is, in the days of arrangement, a kind of temporary partner to the surviving spouse. They walk through the options, they explain costs, they manage timelines, they coordinate with the cemetery and the clergy, they handle the obituary if asked. Thomas Lynch has described the role as part undertaker, part stage manager, part grief counselor, part lawyer's clerk. The surviving spouse, in shock, often leans heavily on the funeral director, and the quality of this temporary collaboration shapes the funeral significantly. Funeral directors who push for expensive options without reading the family well are remembered with bitterness. Funeral directors who listen and protect the family from their own first-night decisions are remembered with gratitude.

The decision about the casket — wood, metal, simple, ornate, present, not present — is one of the most consequential aesthetic decisions of the funeral. It is also one of the most upsold. The American funeral industry has historically generated significant margin from casket markup, and the surviving spouse, in shock, is in a poor position to negotiate. Doughty and others in the death-positive movement have advocated for simpler caskets, home funerals, and natural burial in part as a response to this dynamic. The casket question is bound up with the open-casket question, which is bound up with the embalming question, and each decision has implications for cost, for ritual, and for how the surviving spouse last sees the body.

The obituary is a small literary form, and it is usually composed by a family member — often the surviving spouse or a child — in a hurry, under grief, for a deadline. It will appear in the local paper, online, on social media, and it will be read by people who knew the deceased and people who did not. Composing it requires deciding, in a few hundred words, what the marriage and the life were about. Survivors who can delegate this writing to a literate child or friend often do. Survivors who write it themselves often describe it later as one of the harder hours of the first week — a forced act of summary at a moment when nothing yet summarizes.

The order of service is the document the congregation holds during the funeral, and it is also a kind of program for the marriage as a whole. It lists hymns, readings, speakers, sometimes a photo on the cover. The surviving spouse, in selecting these elements, is making editorial choices about what the marriage was. The hymn the couple sang at their wedding often returns here, half a century later, as a closing rather than an opening. Particular readings — 1 Corinthians 13, Mary Oliver, Wendell Berry, Auden's Funeral Blues — function almost as standard texts in contemporary American funerals, and the surviving spouse chooses among them or finds something more specific to the partner.

Who speaks at the funeral is a delicate question. The surviving spouse rarely delivers the central eulogy themselves — the emotional load is usually too much — but they often choose the speakers. Adult children frequently speak. A long-standing friend speaks. Sometimes a colleague. The eulogies are the canonical public version of the deceased, and the surviving spouse listens to them in the front row, hearing their partner described by other people, sometimes hearing stories they had never heard before. Many widows and widowers later report that the eulogies revealed sides of their partner that the marriage had not seen, and that this was both a gift and a small grief of its own.

If there is a burial, there is a procession from the service to the cemetery, and there is a graveside committal. The procession is a slow drive with headlights on, and the graveside committal is a short, often outdoor ritual in which the casket is lowered or the urn is placed and a few last words are said. This is, for many surviving spouses, the most physically difficult moment of the funeral — the literal lowering of the body, the literal end of the visible presence of the partner. Lynch has written about the importance of this moment and about the way modern funerals sometimes skip it, to the long-term cost of the bereaved.

After the service the surviving spouse stands, often for two or three hours, and accepts condolences from everyone who attended. This is one of the most exhausting social performances of widowhood. The widow or widower hears the same phrases over and over — I'm so sorry, he was a wonderful man, she was such a kind person, you're in our prayers — and must respond, over and over, with thank you for coming. Lopata's research on widowhood notes that this receiving line is often where the new identity is publicly assigned: the surviving spouse is, for the first time, being treated by the community as a widow or widower, and the treatment will continue, in modified form, for years.

The reception is usually held at a church hall, a restaurant, or the family home. There is food, often catered, often brought by neighbors. People talk. Children run around. The surviving spouse circulates, or sits, depending on energy. The reception is the first occasion at which the community sees the surviving spouse outside the formal role of mourner, and the social calibration begins — who will continue to invite them, who will quietly drop them, who will become more present. Lieberman has written about the reception as the threshold between the formal ritual and the long unstructured grief that follows.

Funerals in the United States routinely cost between eight and fifteen thousand dollars, and elaborate funerals cost much more. The surviving spouse, in shock, is often asked to make these financial decisions in the first forty-eight hours, with limited capacity for cost-benefit analysis. The death-positive movement and the simpler-funeral movement have both grown partly in response to this dynamic. Many widows and widowers report later that they spent more than they wished and that they did not realize, at the time, that less expensive options were available or appropriate. Pre-planning, again, mitigates this — the price questions can be settled when the partner is still alive and the surviving spouse is not yet in shock.

The day after the funeral is a particular kind of empty. The visitors have left. The casseroles are in the fridge. The order of service is on the kitchen table. The surviving spouse, who has been performing for the community for a week, is suddenly alone with the absence. Many widows and widowers describe this day as the real beginning of widowhood — the funeral was a structure, and now the structure is gone. The collective project of the funeral is complete, and the long, mostly solitary collective project of grief, supported by a community that will gradually withdraw, begins.

The funeral leaves behind a set of artifacts: the program, the guest book, the casseroles, the photos used, the recording of the service if there was one, the obituary clipping. These artifacts become objects in the surviving spouse's house, sometimes for decades. The funeral also leaves behind a story — what the eulogies said, what people said in the receiving line, what happened at the reception — and the story enters the family canon. The partnership that built the funeral has ended, but the funeral itself becomes one of the partnership's last collaborative outputs, and the surviving spouse will refer back to it, in private, for the rest of their life.

1. Lynch, Thomas. The Undertaking: Life Studies from the Dismal Trade. New York: W. W. Norton, 1997. 2. Doughty, Caitlin. Smoke Gets in Your Eyes: And Other Lessons from the Crematory. New York: W. W. Norton, 2014. 3. Doughty, Caitlin. From Here to Eternity: Traveling the World to Find the Good Death. New York: W. W. Norton, 2017. 4. Lopata, Helena Z. Widowhood in an American City. Cambridge, MA: Schenkman, 1973. 5. Lieberman, Susan. The Mourning After: How to Manage Grief Wisely in a Stupid Culture. New York: Rowman and Littlefield, 2019. 6. Mitford, Jessica. The American Way of Death Revisited. New York: Knopf, 1998. 7. Lynch, Thomas. The Good Funeral: Death, Grief, and the Community of Care. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 2013. 8. Gawande, Atul. Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End. New York: Metropolitan Books, 2014. 9. Bonanno, George A. The Other Side of Sadness: What the New Science of Bereavement Tells Us About Life After Loss. New York: Basic Books, 2009. 10. Prigerson, Holly G., et al. "Prolonged Grief Disorder: Psychometric Validation of Criteria Proposed for DSM-V and ICD-11." PLoS Medicine 6, no. 8 (2009): e1000121. 11. Callanan, Maggie, and Patricia Kelley. Final Gifts: Understanding the Special Awareness, Needs, and Communications of the Dying. New York: Bantam, 1992. 12. Miller, BJ, and Shoshana Berger. A Beginner's Guide to the End: Practical Advice for Living Life and Facing Death. New York: Simon and Schuster, 2019.